New message · comparison

Newoldstamp Alternative: BrandFooter vs Newoldstamp

See how BrandFooter compares to Newoldstamp for team email signatures: one-time payment vs per-user subscription, claim links vs admin provisioning.

Newoldstamp treats email signatures as a marketing channel. Banner campaigns, click tracking, department-level targeting: it is a genuinely capable platform, and it is priced like one, with a per-user subscription that renews for as long as you use it.

That pricing stings most for teams who do not need the marketing layer. A 15-person company that wants matching, professional signatures does the real work once, in the first week. Then the invoices keep arriving: every month, and a little higher after every hire.

BrandFooter flips the model. You pay a flat one-time price that covers your whole team, set up a template, and send each person a claim link to copy their signature. Output is table-based HTML with inline styles, so it survives Gmail, Outlook, and Apple Mail. If you run quarterly banner campaigns and need click analytics, Newoldstamp justifies its subscription. If you just want signatures handled, you can stop renting them.

Re: The alternatives

How Newoldstamp compares

An honest look at what each platform does well and where it falls short.

Newoldstamp

Newoldstamp treats email signatures as a marketing channel. Banner campaigns, click tracking, department-level targeting: it is a genuinely capable platform, and it is priced like one, with a per-user subscription that renews for as long as you use it. That pricing stings most for teams who do not need the marketing layer. A 15-person company that wants matching, professional signatures does the real work once, in the first week. Then the invoices keep arriving: every month, and a little higher after every hire. BrandFooter flips the model. You pay a flat one-time price that covers your whole team, set up a template, and send each person a claim link to copy their signature. Output is table-based HTML with inline styles, so it survives Gmail, Outlook, and Apple Mail. If you run quarterly banner campaigns and need click analytics, Newoldstamp justifies its subscription. If you just want signatures handled, you can stop renting them.

Subscription

Strengths

  • One flat payment covers every current and future teammate
  • Claim links get each person their signature without creating an account
  • Table-based, inline-styled HTML renders correctly in Outlook's Word engine
  • Setup takes minutes and needs no IT involvement
  • Free generator to test the output before paying anything

Drawbacks

  • No banner campaign scheduling or click analytics yet (analytics are on the roadmap)
  • No server-side injection, signatures are installed in each email client
  • Fewer integrations than Newoldstamp, no CRM or marketing platform hooks
  • Google Workspace auto-deploy is planned but not shipped
Best for:

Enterprise teams

Re: Why BrandFooter

Why teams choose BrandFooter

Built for small teams who want professional email signatures without the complexity or recurring fees.

Re: Common questions

Frequently asked questions

Common questions about switching and choosing the right tool.

Is BrandFooter cheaper than Newoldstamp?+

For most small teams, yes, and the gap widens every year. Newoldstamp bills per user per month, so a growing team pays more each renewal. BrandFooter is a single flat payment that covers the whole team, so year two onward costs nothing.

What does Newoldstamp do better than BrandFooter?+

Signature marketing. Newoldstamp offers scheduled banner campaigns, click tracking, and integrations with sales and marketing tools. BrandFooter skips that layer on purpose to stay simple and affordable, so if banner campaigns are part of your marketing calendar, Newoldstamp is the better fit.

How do I roll out signatures to my team with BrandFooter?+

You build a template with your logo, colors, and layout, then send each teammate a claim link. They open it, check their details, and copy the finished signature into Gmail, Outlook, or Apple Mail. Nobody needs to create an account or learn a dashboard.

Will BrandFooter signatures break in Outlook?+

No. Every template compiles to table-based HTML with inline styles, which is the only markup that renders reliably in Outlook's desktop Word engine as well as Gmail and Apple Mail. There are no div layouts, web fonts, or stylesheets to get stripped.

Can BrandFooter push signatures automatically like Newoldstamp's integrations?+

Not yet. Today each person installs their signature once via a claim link, which takes about a minute. Automatic deployment through the Google Workspace API is on the roadmap, and signature analytics are planned for a later phase.

Why choose BrandFooter over Newoldstamp?

One-time payment. No subscriptions. Your whole team covered.